Brother HL-L5100DN vs Canon imageCLASS LBP236dw

Detailed Technical Comparison & Buying Guide

Brother HL-L5100DN Brother HL-L5100DN
VS
Canon imageCLASS LBP236dw Canon imageCLASS LBP236dw

Brother HL-L5100DN

✅ A legitimate workhorse built for high-volume monthly duty cycles.
❌ No built-in Wi-Fi on the 'DN' model; it's Ethernet or USB only.

Canon imageCLASS LBP236dw

✅ Exceptional first-page speed; the printer is finished before you stand up.
❌ The design is very 'traditional office'—it won't win any beauty contests.
Feature Brother HL-L5100DN Canon imageCLASS LBP236dw
Print Technology Monochrome Laser Monochrome Laser
Colour Output Black Black
Print Resolution 1200 x 1200 dpi 600 x 600 dpi
Black Print Speed (PPM) 42 ppm 40 ppm
Colour Print Speed (PPM) N/A N/A
First Page Out Time 7.2 sec 5.4 sec
Auto Double-Sided Yes Yes
Input Paper Capacity 250 Sheets 250 Sheets
Output Tray Capacity 150 Sheets 150 Sheets
Supported Paper Sizes A4, A5, A6, B5 A4, A5, A6, B5
Paper Weight Support 60-120 g/m2 60-163 g/m2
Scanner Type None None
Scan Resolution N/A N/A
Auto Document Feeder None None
Copy Speed No No
Wi-Fi Connectivity No Yes
Ethernet Support Yes Yes
USB Connectivity Yes Yes
Mobile Printing Support Yes Yes
Display Panel N/A N/A
Monthly Duty Cycle N/A N/A
Ink/Cartridge System N/A N/A
Borderless Printing N/A N/A
Width N/A N/A
Depth N/A N/A
Height N/A N/A
Machine Weight N/A N/A
Energy Efficiency N/A N/A
Noise Level (dB) N/A N/A
Processor Speed N/A N/A
Internal Memory N/A N/A
Cloud Print Support N/A N/A
Security Features N/A N/A
Compatible OS N/A N/A
Included in Box N/A N/A
Warranty Period N/A N/A
Recommended Use N/A N/A

⚖️ Expert Verdict

This is a showdown between two of the most reliable monochrome engines in the industry. The Canon LBP236dw offers a staggering 40ppm and a very intuitive touchscreen interface, which rivals the Brother’s performance. However, the HL-L5100DN provides a more established platform for third-party software integration and a more rugged manual feed slot for specialty media. It’s a tight race, but the Brother L5100DN takes the win for users who prioritize mechanical serviceability and long-term part availability, while the Canon remains a fantastic choice for modern UI-driven environments.

What Owners Are Saying?

Brother HL-L5100DN

Law_Firm_LDN
"We’ve got this tucked away in the back room and it prints 200+ contracts a day without a single jam. It's a proper workhorse. No fancy touchscreen to break, just buttons and raw speed. If you need a departmental mono laser that won't let you down, this is it. Absolute unit."

Canon imageCLASS LBP236dw

Office_Assistant
"The large touchscreen makes this a doddle to use. It’s fast, quiet, and handles heavy duty cycles without a flicker. Strategic win for our team."

More Comparisons